I find this pencil so easy to use and does your brows look so natural. The shape of this pencil helps you to shape them quick and nicely , you just have to use it in strokes and in the hair direction. I highly recommend this for the every day use as is so easy to use and takes couple of minutes to do it.
Reviewed on Wed 10 Jul 2019
I am in my late teens/early 20's with normal, medium tone skin and unknown eyes. My hair is unknown, unknown with unknown texture.
This just didn’t do anything for me except make my brows look smudgy. It wasn’t very pigmented so it wasn’t doing much to fill in my brows it’s quite chunky as well so it was difficult to do any defined lines. It didn’t work for me at all.
Reviewed on Thu 27 Jun 2019
I am in my late teens/early 20's with oily, light tone skin and unknown eyes. My hair is unknown, unknown with unknown texture.
This is such an easy product to use. Makes brows look sculpted and defined and lasts well throughout the day. The reason I have given this 4 stars is that I think the price point may be slightly high for the amount of product you receive. I think if you are doing beauty on a budget this is definitely not for you. However, if you are willing to spend a little more then this formula is great and works effortlessly.
Reviewed on Mon 11 Mar 2019
I am in my late teens/early 20's with normal, medium tone skin and blue eyes. My hair is blonde, dry with fine texture.
This pencil has a diamond shaped tip rather than a normal pencil tip. The point of the diamond is great for creating strokes if you have a small area to fill in for example a missing tail or front of your eye brow like I have. The fatter end is best for filling in large areas or going over the whole of the eyebrow. I like this pencil for giving me a more natural looking brow and creating hairs where I have some missing. I like to use this pencil when I don’t want to wear my basic face, just eyebrows, eyeliner and mascara. This is my sitting in the house kind of face or popping to the shops. Every person is different and will have an arsenal of products for different days or make-up. This product is in my basic-basic make-up along with Benefit Badgal Bang and Benefit Badgal Waterproof eyeliner which means I will be repurchasing it.
Reviewed on Sat 16 Feb 2019
I am in my late 30's/early 40's with sensitive, fair tone skin and hazel eyes. My hair is dark brown, normal with coarse texture.
I recently purchased this brow pencil and was pleasantly surprised. I thought it was going to be like the others I have used and wear off easily but it stayed put all day. Easy to apply and perfect shade for me. Builds up nicely for that fuller look or can be used to touch up for perfect everyday brows.
Reviewed on Wed 13 Feb 2019
I am in my late 20's/early 30's with combination, light tone skin and unknown eyes. My hair is unknown, unknown with unknown texture.
I'm lucky enough to have really dark eyebrows but now I'm getting older they're getting more sparse. My Goof Proof comes in really handy! Without having to press thickly it's a good colour that can be applied lightly for people with fairer brows and, for me, with a bit more of a heavy hand. It strokes on via a slanted nib with a natural looking colour to fill in any gaps, leaving the brows framing the face without looking fake. I love the cool silver pen and it's easy and light to hold. Recommended!
Reviewed on Fri 18 Jan 2019
I am in my late 40's/early 50's with combination, light tone skin and brown eyes. My hair is red, normal with fine texture.
This is actually my go to brow pencil for my morning school run makeup. Gives enough pigment for a natural looking brow. Easily buildable and keeps it's shape. Would like a wider variety of colours though. Will rebuy and would recommend.
Reviewed on Fri 18 Jan 2019
I am in my late 20's/early 30's with combination, light tone skin and green eyes. My hair is red, combination with normal texture.
I got this in the magic brow gift set from a sale online and I'm in love!
I love how natural and dark my brows look after using this and it's soft and smooth.
The texture is different and isn't powdery meaning you can control it so this is something I will be defo buying again.
Reviewed on Sat 05 Jan 2019
I am in my mid 20's with oily, olive tone skin and brown eyes. My hair is dark brown, normal with normal texture.
This product gives a beautiful natural look but still helps define your brows, brought as a present but i’m definitely purchasing from here again when i run out, would recommend to anyone thinking about it
Reviewed on Mon 10 Dec 2018
I am in my late teens with dry, light tone skin and unknown eyes. My hair is unknown, unknown with unknown texture.
overall, I think that this is a really nice brow pencil. It is easy to apply, fills in your eyebrows quickly and it doesn't smudge. This is a good product if you want a natural looking brow but it is also good for creating bold looking brows. I would definitely buy this again but maybe in a darker shade although the shade I have now (blonde) is a good shade for me.
Reviewed on Sun 12 Aug 2018
I am in my late teens with combination, light tone skin and hazel eyes. My hair is blonde, combination with fine texture.
I’ve never really been into filling in my brows because I never could find something that looked good. Oh my word does this brow pencil work! So easy to use and it matches my eyebrow colour very well. Well worth trying! X
Reviewed on Sat 12 May 2018
I am in my late teens with combination, fair tone skin and blue eyes. My hair is blonde, normal with unknown texture.
I am terrible with rushing my brows ! I’m just lazy so get up late and need a quick fix in all honestly 😂 ! And this is the best product I’ve used so far. Quick brush. Shape and brush through and there done ! Which a little ka brow and away we go. The name is so true it’s 100% goof proof 🙄.
Reviewed on Fri 11 May 2018
I am in my late 20's/early 30's with combination, fair tone skin and green eyes. My hair is blonde, combination with fine texture.
As an absolute brow novice I loved how easy to use this was. It’s not super heavily pigmented but it’s buildable if you want a more defined colour or you can stick to a subtle look. Which for someone like me who is quite likely to make mistakes is great. Lasts all day and paired with their brow gel I felt super confident.
Reviewed on Tue 24 Apr 2018
I am in my mid 20's with dry, fair tone skin and unknown eyes. My hair is unknown, unknown with unknown texture.
I bought this one like a couple of months ago and I recently opened the cap off the side and it straight away snapped in half. it was actually quite good brow pencil apart from when it broke off I would actually buy this product again to be honest.
Reviewed on Tue 02 Jan 2018
I am in my teens with dry, fair tone skin and unknown eyes. My hair is unknown, unknown with unknown texture.
I’ve been using this eyebrow pencil for a while now. I use shade 3 and it’s the perfect shade for me. I love the angled tip and the easy to use tube.
It stays on all day, really love it and wouldn’t use anything else now :)
Reviewed on Wed 18 Oct 2017
I am in my mid 30's with dry, light tone skin and green eyes. My hair is blonde, dry with fine texture.
This product is good it does the job but I don't think the tip is really helpful at the start of the eyebrows because you want a straight application and can be quite hard to get that but at the end of the eyebrow it is helpful to get that thin application in place it provides a soft and easy application which you can build up so for people like me who do not want really dark eyebrows, to make it more darker you would have to apply a bit of pressure and swipe it more to get the colour. It lasts all day as well which is good.
Reviewed on Fri 13 Oct 2017
I am in my late teens/early 20's with normal, tanned tone skin and brown eyes. My hair is black, normal with normal texture.
I personally try to go for a more natural look with my brows and can achieve that very well with this product. It is not too heavily pigmented so for more definition you have to swipe it a few times over the same area, but because of this I find it very easy to control how well defined you want your eyebrows to look. The only downfall with this product is that after some time the nip of the pencil can get a bit blunt, so can be a bit inconvenient if you want to achieve a sharper line. I would definitely buy this product again!
Reviewed on Tue 29 Aug 2017
I am in my late teens/early 20's with normal, fair tone skin and hazel eyes. My hair is dark brown, normal with fine texture.
Goof Proof Eyebrow Pencil by Benefit
Where to Buy
Prices last updated 21 August 2019.
Where to Buy
Benefit Goof Proof Eyebrow Pencil is available to buy at Benefit Cosmetics, Fabled, lookfantastic, HQhair.com, John Lewis, Cult Beauty, ASOS, Feelunique, Boots.com, Beauty Expert, and allbeauty.com.