This is a decent mascara, but I found that it dried out really quickly, I may have just gotten an older tube, but it was still disappointing to only have this work for a couple of weeks. I wouldn't say that the formula was any different to other versions of Maybelline Colossal mascaras. The only difference was that there are two bumpy parts on the wand which really does nothing to improve the application. I prefer Essence Lash Princess or Benefit Bad Gal Bang because I can get the volume I want in two coats max, but it took me at least four coats to build up this mascara to get the volume I wamore...nted. However, I think that this is a really good mascara for more natural looks, as I haven't experienced any clumping with this mascara.
Would not buy again