I really like this eyeliner as it's so easy to use! I've always been put off by the felt tip kind of eyeliners but this gives me a precise line and even flicks which I have never been able to do. It is a dark black colour which I like and it doesn't fade that much in the day compared to some other cheaper ones I have used. With a lot of eyeliners I struggle to do get close to my lash line to do a thinner line but with this one I can and I can also do a bolder look with it.
Reviewed on Mon 18 Mar 2019
I am in my late teens/early 20's with acne/problem, fair tone skin and blue eyes. My hair is blonde, dry with fine texture.
I have the Skinny version of this, and I absolutely love it but I think it's cause I don't like the bold eyeliner look for me.
I'm slightly scared of dramatic eyeliner, that's why this product works so well for me! Its precise pen allows me to put just the right amount of liner exactly where I want it. Its amazing for getting really close to your lash line, and creating natural looking liner. Its also really easy to remove if you make a mistake, which I often do.
I have had this product for around four months now and its still the same quality as when I first bought it. But I don't use this product everyday.
Reviewed on Mon 04 Mar 2019
I am in my late teens/early 20's with combination, fair tone skin and unknown eyes. My hair is unknown, unknown with unknown texture.
I was given this as part of a gift set a while ago and started using this liner. It was easy to apply to the lash line and create a wing, however I found that the black liner would fade through out the day which wasn’t great and that the black wasn’t very pigmented. If you’re looking for something long lasting, I wouldn’t recommend.
Reviewed on Sat 05 Jan 2019
I am in my late teens with sensitive, fair tone skin and hazel eyes. My hair is blonde, normal with fine texture.
Beautiful easy application and allowed me to do a really nice cat eye. Unfortunately doesn't stay on very long (especially if you touch your face a lot throughout the day) and smears quite easily. This would be good for people starting out with eyeliner, but the pigment isn't as black and intense as I would like it to be and the lack of last means I probably won't buy this again.
Reviewed on Mon 31 Dec 2018
I am in my late teens/early 20's with sensitive, light tone skin and brown eyes. My hair is medium brown, dry with coarse texture.
I’ve repurchased this so many times. It’s a great price, lasts for ages and it easy to use. It gives a good line which you can make thin or thick. It survives running! Val Garland says she thinks it great and if it’s good enough for her then I’ll keep using it.
Reviewed on Wed 12 Dec 2018
I am in my late 30's/early 40's with normal, light tone skin and green eyes. My hair is blonde, normal with fine texture.
I've been in love with the Soap&Glory bath products for so long that I've decided to try their makeup. What a disappointment. This eyeliner is more of a dark chocolate colour than the promised carbon Black. It is fairly easy to use but it doesn't really stay in place for more than 2/3 hours (half day into work and I had to redo my makeup as it smudged everywhere) . Very disappointed as you can find better eyeliners for a lower price.
Reviewed on Sat 08 Sep 2018
I am in my mid 20's with combination, light tone skin and brown eyes. My hair is dark brown, combination with coarse texture.
I normally prefer a brush applicator liquid eyeliner, but got this as a present and thought I'd better try it. It's very easy to apply but you need to apply a bit of pressure to get a solid line, but then you end up having a thicker line than you wanted. It's also just "quite" pigmented so ok for casual looks, the nib is quite stiff, and it comes off easily, which is also an advantage I guess! Slightly worried about it drying out too as I've heard pens do unless you store them nib down. I don't dislike it, but I probably won't be repurchasing.
Reviewed on Fri 24 Aug 2018
I am in my late 20's/early 30's with combination, fair tone skin and blue eyes. My hair is red, normal with normal texture.
I bought this after a bunch of Beauty Vloggers raved about this eyeliner pen. Don’t believe the hype, it’s an alright eyeliner but the formula pills and the nib requires some pressure to produce a solid black line. The point of the pen does not stay sharp for long despite careful use and has also started to dry up. It is okay if you need to quickly tightline or create an understated look, but for a dramatic cat eye I would look for a true black, waterproof, smudge resistant and sharp applicator. This pen is and has none of those things. I find rimmel’s Exaggerate Hydrofuge liner much better.
Reviewed on Sun 29 Jul 2018
I am in my late teens/early 20's with oily, black tone skin and brown eyes. My hair is black, afro with fine texture.
I like to use a pen eyeliner over any other product as it find it the easiest to control as someone who only starting using eyeliner on my eyelids within the last year. The Supercat eyeliner is so far the best one I’ve tried, it doesn’t dry out when I’m using it, it gives a good black line and hasn’t leaked everywhere like a previous product I had. I will repurchase this product and keep it in my collection as a favourite.
Reviewed on Sat 14 Apr 2018
I am in my late 20's/early 30's with dry, tanned tone skin and grey eyes. My hair is medium brown, combination with normal texture.
I have the ‘skinny’ version of this eyeliner. I like the shape of the nib but it is much too stiff and scratchy for my liking. I prefer a more flexible nib like the L’Oréal Perfect Slim Eyeliner. However the colour is a much more intense black than the L’Oréal product therefore I use these two eyeliners in combination. I tend to draw a rough line with the Supercat Skinny and apply my flick and neaten up with the L’Oréal liner.
Reviewed on Fri 16 Mar 2018
I am in my late 20's/early 30's with combination, fair tone skin and hazel eyes. My hair is medium brown, combination with coarse texture.
This liner is incredibly black and is easy to apply. My main issue is that it smudges incredibly easy with the slightest contact with water which is not ideal. While I wouldn't repurchase this one again, I would consider the super cat skinny because of the incredibly fine tip.
Reviewed on Wed 27 Dec 2017
I am in my late teens/early 20's with acne/problem, fair tone skin and hazel eyes. My hair is blonde, oily with fine texture.
Im not great at liner on my lid due to my hands shaking lots and i also blink alot, but using this makes it easy. So what i do is lay the tip on its side and lightly press working from the inner corner out. When i get past half way i then lay the whole of the nib on its side to make the line thicker and either stop at the outer corner or turn the pen so the point faces outwards and then press the whole nib on to create the flick. This gives great results and is great for beginners or those who struggle due to shakes etc. Just make sure to take your time.
Reviewed on Fri 01 Sep 2017
I am in my mid 30's with dry, light tone skin and blue eyes. My hair is red, dry with normal texture.
It does the job but in my opinion it's not black enough and doesn't last well. Love the shape and flexibility of the tip/nib but the product itself is questionable if it is good. And I tell you know, it stinks of chemicals.
Reviewed on Sun 05 Feb 2017
I am in my late teens with acne/problem, fair tone skin and hazel eyes. My hair is red, normal with coarse texture.
I love this eye liner, it's my life saver! I have a bit of a shaky hand when doing eye liner so it's so nice to have something that just always looks perfect! It provides a gorgeous wing with a sharp flick which is what I'm really after! Nice and cheap and lasts me years considering I wear it every day!
Reviewed on Sat 14 Jan 2017
I am in my late teens/early 20's with normal, olive tone skin and brown eyes. My hair is light brown, oily with normal texture.
I swatched the tester on my arm and loved how clear the colour was and some eyeliners are pretty dull. I was disappointed as it is quite difficult to apply, and fades away quickly so you'd have to keep applying. Doesn't really give a sharp winged eyeliner look, bit of a waste.
Reviewed on Thu 10 Nov 2016
I am in my late teens with sensitive, tanned tone skin and hazel eyes. My hair is blonde, normal with fine texture.
Supercat™ Carbon Black Extreme by Soap & Glory
Where to Buy
Prices last updated 25 August 2019.
Where to Buy
Soap & Glory Supercat™ Carbon Black Extreme is available to buy at Boots.com.