I was sent this by GlamGeek for reviewer of the week (thank you!). I really enjoyed trying out this product. I have found the pencil glides on smoothly and does not tug at my eye lids. This pencil blends easily with your fingertip of an angled eyeliner brush, so is great for a smokey eye. I also managed to create a subtle winged eyeliner. I will definitely be using this pencil regularly.
Reviewed on Sat 19 Mar 2016
I am in my late teens with combination, fair tone skin and blue eyes. My hair is light brown, dry with normal texture.
i think this pen is so over priced it is no better than a £5 product and it is annoying it been so thick because there are hardlyy any sharpeners that fit it just dont think its very good for the price
Reviewed on Tue 04 Jan 2011
I am in my late teens/early 20's with combination, light tone skin and brown eyes. My hair is blonde, combination with normal texture.
Nice dark colour, as some can appear grey. Unfortunately it is not very creamy and can tug at eyelids. It retails around £12 i believe however i got mine free in a magazine, glad i didnt dish out £12 for mine. If applied to the underneath of eyes it does not last long AT ALL!
Reviewed on Sat 25 Dec 2010
I am in my mid 20's with oily, medium tone skin and green eyes. My hair is dark brown, processed with normal texture.
Doesn't seem to glide on very well (might have something to do with the thickness of the pencil) and it's quite hard to get an accurate line. Better for a bolder look but because it is so thick I have to sharpen it constantly which means it's running out quicker than any other eyeliner I've bought in the past.
Reviewed on Wed 08 Dec 2010
I am in my late 20's/early 30's with combination, light tone skin and brown eyes. My hair is dark brown, combination with normal texture.
Was not impressed with this product for it's price and Benefits reputation! Didn't apply very well and certaintly didn't last, wasn't a strong, bold, defining colour, overall not at all impressed and not worth the money!
Reviewed on Thu 11 Nov 2010
I am in my mid 20's with dry, medium tone skin and brown eyes. My hair is dark brown, normal with normal texture.
This eyeliner has a really good, dark pigment and it's soft texture makes applying it very easy and great for achieving smokey looks. However, because it is so soft it means that it rubs off easily and isn't ideal for everyday use.
Reviewed on Sat 23 Oct 2010
I am in my late teens/early 20's with combination, fair tone skin and hazel eyes. My hair is light brown, oily with normal texture.
I got it free with an issue of Glamour Magazine, and I think it's the best eyeliner I've ever used! It's nice and soft so it doesn't drag on the delicate eyelid skin, really easy to erase mistakes and the deep black pigment still managed to look nicely subtle on my fair complexion!
Reviewed on Tue 27 Jul 2010
I am in my mid 20's with combination, light tone skin and blue eyes. My hair is blonde, combination with normal texture.
I really like this chunky kohl pencil. Great for a smudgy smoky look as it is easy to smudge. Good on waterline as it is so well pigmented and pretty soft, so no scratching your eyeball! Good on lash lines although it was. Great!
Reviewed on Tue 27 Jul 2010
I am in my late 30's/early 40's with combination, medium tone skin and hazel eyes. My hair is dark brown, oily with normal texture.
i don't really like this product it is very big and smudges way to easily also it is very creamy like the other benefit pencils such as eye bright, it stick etc.. i suppose you could take the features of this product into a positive way but i really don't like this i think the whole benefit bad gal line is just bad quality and highly priced
Reviewed on Mon 26 Jul 2010
I am in my late teens/early 20's with normal, tanned tone skin and blue eyes. My hair is dark brown, oily with normal texture.