Mascara

Top 20 Mascara Products for September 2015

We want to be able to cry whilst watching Titanic and still look glamorous, get caught in the rain without getting panda eyes and have 1-inch lashes that look like falsies but aren’t. Our mascara should stay put from morning till night, but come off with one wipe of cleanser!

Choosing the right one is essential as it can result in the difference between having bambi-esque eyes or scary tarantula eyes. Whatever effect you want to achieve, longer, fuller and curled or thicker, volumised and bold we are here at glamgeek to help with the task in hand.

1st
Extra Super Lash Mascara by Rimmel
GlamGeek Rating:
4.9
(12 reviews)
Non-Mover in the top 20 this month.
Extra Super Lash Mascara Reviews:
"This mascara makes your lashes look super long! I love the brush as the mascara doesn"t feel heavy on your eyes or clog up"

"This mascara is definatly a go-to mascara. Over the past 2 years since my first purchase of this mascara I have tried many others and have always gone back to this product. Soley for the reason that it makes my eyelashes sand out with the right consistancy or product. It isn"t too runny and it isn"t too clumpy and always makes my eyes look a whole lot better. I swear by it!"


More Reviews (12) »
2nd
Hypnose Precious Cells by Lancome
The 1st lash care mascara with precious apple extract by Lancôme. A lasting formula that helps regenerate lash condition. Lashes feel stronger, look denser as if visibly multiplied.
GlamGeek Rating:
4.7
(6 reviews)
Non-Mover in the top 20 this month.
Hypnose Precious Cells Reviews:
"I really did love this mascara it provided excellent volume and length without clumping and my eyelashes looked amazing, the only downside is that it"s very expensive so for those on a budget it"s overly priced therefore I probably wouldn"t repurchase unless I had money to spare."

"There is onyl one disadvantage with this product and thats the price. However, I would definitely pay the money again as it's well worth it. This is one of the best mascara i have come across and the brush is my favourite. It helps to elongate the lashes to their fullest whilst keeping them clump free. Because of the tip, it's easy to reach into the inner and outer corners of the eye lashes. "


More Reviews (6) »
3rd
Lash & Brow Perfector by Boots No7
No7 Lash & Brow Perfector is a caring, conditioning gel to enhance and shape your lashes and brows.
GlamGeek Rating:
4.6
(5 reviews)
Non-Mover in the top 20 this month.
Lash & Brow Perfector Reviews:
"this is flawless for a natural makeup look on eyelashes but not great on brows"

"This is the best brow perfector I have used. It goes on smoothly and keeps eyebrows in place."


More Reviews (5) »
4th
Falsies Big Eyes Mascara by Maybelline
Now get bigger, wide-open eyes with 360 degrees of lash glam volume! The Upper Brush pushes lashes over the top while the lower Micro-Brush grabs every tiny bottom lash for a full circle effect.
GlamGeek Rating:
4.6
(5 reviews)
Non-Mover in the top 20 this month.
Falsies Big Eyes Mascara Reviews:
"It is really good mascara and it doesn"t smudge easily!! It makes your lashes look big and bold without putting on too much, it stays on for a long time but it comes off easily with facial wipes and makeup remover "

"This is the best mascara I have ever used, it makes your eyelashes look so big its unbelievable. I have recommended this to many of my friends and they say that it is an amazing product to use. Since I have tried this I never picked up another mascara. It lasts a long amount of time, but it really depends on how often you use it."


More Reviews (5) »
5th
Masterpiece Waterproof Mascara by Max Factor
Frame your eyes with beautiful, striking lashes. Our high-tech IFX brush evenly coats lashes giving superb definition and separation. Five times more striking vs. bare lashes based on lash volume, count, contrast area and visibility.
GlamGeek Rating:
4.6
(23 reviews)
Non-Mover in the top 20 this month.
Masterpiece Waterproof Mascara Reviews:
"this is amazing. It gives you long spread lashes in one coat and it is buildable. I have been using this mascara for about a year, it lasts at least 2 months and I am always quick to re-purchase it."

"This product is the best out of all the Max Factor range, i really liked it and it didn't smuge when i went swimming."


More Reviews (23) »
6th
Full Exposure Mascara by Smashbox
Inspired by Smashbox's on-set technique of layering fiber mascara over volumizing mascara for the biggest, longest lashes on camera, Full Exposure Mascara creates a 104% increase in lash volume for scene-stealing lashes at every angle without smudging.
GlamGeek Rating:
4.6
(8 reviews)
Non-Mover in the top 20 this month.
Full Exposure Mascara Reviews:
"As much as I love smashbox cosmetics this mascara really did not do that much for me. The wand was just too big for my liking so I couldn"t get close enough to the root of my lashes. For the rather expensive price tag it simply did not measure up. I will be sticking to my lash sensational from now on. "

"This is very good. Does not clump and is easy to apply and love the brush. Seems to stay put all day and is also easy to remove when required.Only down side is, im unsure if its worth the price tag, its not cheap."


More Reviews (8) »
7th
Haute & Naughty Lash by MAC
A two-in-one mascara that lets you choose if you want lashes to be naturally defined, or instantly combed and loaded for full-on drama.
GlamGeek Rating:
4.6
(8 reviews)
Non-Mover in the top 20 this month.
Haute & Naughty Lash Reviews:
"This is my favourite mascara by far! I love that you can use it for a more natural look in the daytime and go for a false lash appearance by night, I mostly only use two coats and it make my eyelashes look much more fuller and longer. This is my ultimate go to mascara any time of the day, honestly one of the best products I have owned."

"I have rubbish eyelashes and this is the only mascara I found that made my lashes look good! Definitely recommend and will definitely buy again :)"


More Reviews (8) »
8th
False Lash Mascara Superstar by L'Oreal
A 2-step mascara for super-sized, super-long, superstar lashes that steal the show.
GlamGeek Rating:
4.6
(3 reviews)
Non-Mover in the top 20 this month.
False Lash Mascara Superstar Reviews:
"This is definitely one of my favourite mascara that I have tried from L"Oreal. This mascara makes your lashes extremely black, thick, and false like- which is good. It also holds the curl in your lashes all day. The mascara lasts all day and does not run at all. I especially love the application which is metal like, and spreads your lashes out perfectly. Also very easy to remove."

"This is one of my all time favourite mascara. You can you a lot,e or a lot and it"s comes out perfect each time. I love using this mascara for party events because it gives the false lash effect without the false lashes. I personally find this mascara perfect for sport as it does not run and stays in tact all day. "


More Reviews (3) »
9th
Masterpiece Max Mascara by Max Factor
Max Factor Masterpiece MAX Mascara that gives you the smoothest, A high-impact, volumising mascara creates bold, smooth, sleek lashes with up to four times your bare-lash volume.
GlamGeek Rating:
4.6
(17 reviews)
Non-Mover in the top 20 this month.
Masterpiece Max Mascara Reviews:
"My favourite mascara of all time! This a great mascara for volume and length, been using this mascara for years and it has never let me down. Jet black colour makes your eyes stand out."

"The brush is round, tapered and has lots of dense rubber bristles.I love the volume and length it gives while keeping your lashes nicely separated. Another bonus is that the formula is really, really dark which I love. "


More Reviews (17) »
10th
Lash Extension Effect Mascara by Max Factor
transforms your lashes into a dramatic fan of length. If you loved False Lash Effect for dramatic volume, you will love Lash Extension Effect for dramatic length.
GlamGeek Rating:
4.6
(3 reviews)
Non-Mover in the top 20 this month.
Lash Extension Effect Mascara Reviews:
"It definitely makes my eyelashes look longer, doesn"t make a mess, and it"s easy to apply. It"s also clump free :) but I don"t recommend it if you also want thick eyelashes."

"This is one of the only mascaras I"ve tried that truely gives me astonishing length. It separates my lases well, gives a good coat and lengthens them without clumping. It looks really natual and the formula is great! It does exactly what is says on the tube and I love it so much!"


More Reviews (3) »
11th
Va Va Voom Volume Mascara by Boots Seventeen
GlamGeek Rating:
4.5
(6 reviews)
Non-Mover in the top 20 this month.
Va Va Voom Volume Mascara Reviews:
"Love this mascara! The brush is a nice shape, and you can lengthen your lashes with minimal coats! It also doesn"t make my eyelashes clumpy which I like."

"this mascara is amazingggg, made my eye lashes so long and thick, without them looking clumpy"


More Reviews (6) »
12th
2000 Calorie Mascara by Max Factor
Dramatic Look Volumising Mascara for 300% more volume that's smudgeproof. Elegance is timeless. For over two decades, this classic mascara has been a make-up artist's favourite.
GlamGeek Rating:
4.5
(11 reviews)
Non-Mover in the top 20 this month.
2000 Calorie Mascara Reviews:
"Very thick and difficult to remove. Clumps often. However it is still very volumising and accentuates the eye nicely. "

"I have tried every mascara from the bargain ranges to the high end ranges and will always come back to this. It doesn"t clump. It lengthens and volumises my lashes. It never smudges or leaves flaky bits under my eyes. I wear two coats for work and three coats for a night out. Love it!"


More Reviews (11) »
13th
Le Volume De Chanel by Chanel
Instant volume and intense curves from the first stroke with longer, plumper and thicker lashes. Lashes are coated in deep colour, giving eyes a wide-open effect.
GlamGeek Rating:
4.4
(2 reviews)
Non-Mover in the top 20 this month.
Le Volume De Chanel Reviews:
"This is my go to mascara. I have naturally long lashes, but this adds both definition and volume. I have had many compliments using this product, suggesting my lashes are false! I use eyelash curlers first to give lift to my lashes and then i apply two coats. It lasts all day, but does somethimes it smudge a little. I lovely the packaging and it lasts a long time, so value for money!"


More Reviews (2) »
14th
Volume Express ColossalSmokey by Maybelline
Lush collagen-enriched plumping formula and Mega Brush instantly build 9X volume, without clumps
GlamGeek Rating:
4.4
(21 reviews)
Non-Mover in the top 20 this month.
Volume Express ColossalSmokey Reviews:
"This is amazing. My eye lashes looked really long and I had no difficulties with clumps. I use this mascara all the time and it makes my eyelashes look fuller."

"I"m quite lucky in that I have naturally long, thick eyelashes so this works great on me to add definition. Brush picks up plenty of product and applies easily, separating lashes without any clumps. Had this mascara a few months now and still hasn"t turned clumpy. A thin coat for daytime lasts through an 8 hour day at work, although a thicker night time look needs more maintenance."


More Reviews (21) »
15th
Roller Lash by Benefit
Super Curling and Lifting Mascara. The Hook ‘n’ Roll™ brush with custom-designed hooks to help catch, lift and curl the lashes. Paired with a ink-black, lightweight formula to keep the curl for a whopping 12 hours!.
GlamGeek Rating:
4.4
(32 reviews)
 Up 1 compared to last month.

Roller Lash Reviews:
"Roller Lash is my all time fav! I only use this mascara on weekends as it makes my lashes so long so wearing it at school wouldn"t be a good idea. I absolutely love this mascara as its so easy to apply and isn"t clumpy at all! Totally recommend. "

"Roller Lash by Benefit Cosmetics is one of the best mascaras that I have ever purchased in a long time. This product is really worth the money and works wonders with your lashes, the product lifts lashes and visibly curls them too for long defined, natural looking lashes! The packaging of Roller Lash is unique and different, which is good to grab peoples attention. I would recommend this product! "


More Reviews (32) »
16th
Volume Million Lashes So Couture Mascara by L'Oreal
Refined volume - No clumps - No stiff lashes
GlamGeek Rating:
4.3
(18 reviews)
 Up 1 compared to last month.

Volume Million Lashes So Couture Mascara Reviews:
"This product is packaged very well. However the product itself is a lot less attractive. The wand of this product looks amazing but the performance isn"t great. It makes your lashes clumpy and doesn"t spread them very wel. It also dries up very quickly. I would recommend this product to anyone with fine and thick eye lashes "

"This mascara really helped me I"ve tried so many and all of them other clumped it or it when really long but strait and then I brought this one and instantly I was happy with my result so thanks I would recommend this to every one so thanks a lot "


More Reviews (18) »
17th
Professional Extreme Volume Mascara by MUA Makeup Acadamy
Extreme Volume Mascara magnifies lashes for a spectacular false- lash effect.
GlamGeek Rating:
4.3
(6 reviews)
 Up 1 compared to last month.

Professional Extreme Volume Mascara Reviews:
"I feel like this mascara was good, especially considering it was £1! However, I don"t think I would actually buy this product again due to that fact that it was only average, and I have other mascaras that do more for me. Having said that, this mascara is ideal for those building their makeup collections or who do not wish to spend a great deal of money on something they"ll wash off"

"This was good for £1 I was shocked.it has fibers on the brush so makes lash longer.the brush was quite good.i was using this more than my high end ones.i have a faze of trying new mascaras and I do come back to this one."


More Reviews (6) »
18th
Super Shock Mascara by Avon
For super-big, volumised lashes. Thickening base coat and plumping colour in one with an extra large brush for maximum coverage.
GlamGeek Rating:
4.3
(30 reviews)
 Up 2 compared to last month.

Super Shock Mascara Reviews:
"One of the best mascaras from avon so far, although i found it can be quite clumpy and thickens lashs rather than lengthens them. If you want a dramatic dark and bold look then this mascara is perfect. Abit of a nightmare to remove though"

"I love the volume and length it gives while keeping your lashes nicely separated, it doesn't clump and I think it's more than worth the price, I also love the new tiger print bottle :) a must have for my makeup bag"


More Reviews (30) »
19th
Xxl Volume And Length Mascara by Maybelline
GlamGeek Rating:
4.3
(3 reviews)
 Up 2 compared to last month.

Xxl Volume And Length Mascara Reviews:
"i honestly adore this mascara. It gives you incredibly dark lashes and also very thick and long. I would recommend it to anyone with short lashes that want to make them stand out highly."

"i would highly recommend this mascara. It can be used if you want thin spread out lashes or thick clumpy depending on how much you put on. I"ve had it for about 4 months and still works even though it doesn"t look like it holds alot. You can apply the strengthening mascara and then the actual mascara and it still works as good with or without it."


More Reviews (3) »
20th
Mega Volume Miss Manga Punky Mascara by L'Oreal
The conical shape of the brush catches your top and bottom lashes. The large spaces between the bristles create a Punky comb like effect, that helps style your lashes into spikes.
GlamGeek Rating:
4.3
(9 reviews)
 Up 2 compared to last month.

Mega Volume Miss Manga Punky Mascara Reviews:
"Excellent mascara, makes your eyes really stand out! Works for people with short fine lashes too because it gives you the flase lash effect!! Definitely buy again! "

"This is so good, I use it all the time however I prefer the normal manga eyes to this product as this can sometimes make your eyelashes look clumpy. I recommend using this product and then using a eyelash tool to split you lashes, or buying the original manga eyes."


More Reviews (9) »
To see more products in this category, use the menu at the top of the page.


Top 20's By Type

Please wait...